Film review: Disney's Snow White has a major 'identity crisis'2 hours agoShareSaveNicholas BarberShareSaveDisney

With its creepy CGI dwarfs and muddled tone, Disney's latest live-action remake is "not calamitous" but is a "a mind-boggling mash-up".

Live-action remakes of Disney cartoons aren't usually given a warm welcome by critics and commentators, but none of them has faced as much hostility as the new remake of Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs. Are we succumbing to Disney Princess Fatigue? Maybe, but there's more to it than that. One issue is that the 1937 original was Walt Disney's first ever full-length animated film, and, while parts of it have aged badly, it still stands up as an exquisite, heart-lifting masterpiece. Remaking a revered, all-time great animation as a live-action film is about as sensible as remaking Singin' in the Rain as a cartoon.

Another issue is that Disney's Snow White – to use its official title – has been attacked from both sides of the political spectrum: it has been condemned for being too progressive ("A Disney princess renowned for her pale skin being played by an actress with Colombian heritage? How dare they?"), and not progressive enough ("Caricatured dwarfs in this day and age? How dare they?"). Throw in the pronouncements on the Israel-Gaza war made by its stars, Rachel Zegler and Gal Gadot, and you've got a perfect storm of bad publicity.

The good news for the studio is that the film itself is not so calamitous. It's not the worst of the studio's live-action remakes (that's Robert Zemeckis's straight-to-streaming dud, Pinocchio), and while it's not the best, either, it's undoubtedly the most fascinating. What's so unique about Disney's Snow White is that it seems as if some of the producers wanted to make an old-fashioned tribute to a feudal fairy tale, and the others wanted to make a revisionist, Marxist call-to-arms. Rather than settling on one option or the other, the producers apparently compromised by making both versions at once, so the results are like a mind-boggling mash-up of two different films.

For the first few scenes, what we get is the subversive version. In an overlong opening sequence, we hear that Snow White (Zegler) isn't named after her skin colour, as the traditional story would have it, but after the blizzard that was blowing when she was born. It's not entirely clear why the King and Queen chose to name their daughter in honour of the weather, but considering  she could have been called Drizzle or Gusty Wind, she should probably count herself lucky. The exposition continues with speeches and songs about the days when Snow White's benign parents ruled "a kingdom for the free and the fair", where "the bounty of the land belonged to all who tended it". This has to be the closest a Disney princess film has got to paraphrasing The Communist Manifesto.

Perhaps we should appreciate the value for money: the studio is in effect giving us two films for the price of one

There are more of these radical ideas when Snow White's mother dies, and the King marries a woman who becomes the Evil Queen (Gadot). She warns her subjects of "a terrible threat beyond the southern kingdom", and then exploits their fears to nab the realm's riches for herself. With that, Disney's Snow White becomes one of the year's most bluntly political films – Disney or otherwise. And this is all before Snow White meets her handsome love interest, Jonathan (Andrew Burnap), who is no longer a prince, but the Robin Hood-like leader of a gang of thieves. After he tells Snow White to "stop thinking and start doing", she sings Waiting on a Wish, a song about taking action rather than hoping that things will change for the better. It's a forceful riposte to Disney's earliest fairy-tale cartoons, and leaves you startled by the boldness of the director, Marc Webb, and the writer, Erin Cressida Wilson. As for those people who complained that the trailer felt a bit "woke"? Well, just wait until they see the film.

Once Snow White flees from her homicidal stepmother and hides in the forest, though, her story suddenly turns into a faithful if robotic recreation of the 1937 cartoon. The forest itself looks like a Disneyland ride, with its artificially bright flowers and big-eyed woodland creatures; Zegler looks like a theme-park employee in Snow White's trademark puffy-sleeved dress; and the CGI dwarfs look like creepy animatronic puppets of the classic characters. Choosing to use these weirdly photorealistic digital avatars, rather than putting real actors on the screen, was Webb's worst misjudgement, but this section of the film still works well enough as an homage to the cartoon. Zegler, Gadot and their colleagues all do serviceable jobs, and while Disney's Snow White never matches the airy, twinkling charm of the original, the same could be said of every other Disney remake.

Disney’s Snow White

Director: Marc Webb

Cast: Rachel Zegler, Gal Gadot, Andrew Burnap

Run-time: 1hr 49m

But then it switches back into a revolutionary drama again. Snow White bumps into Jonathan's gang of rebels, and the two of them develop a sparky Princess Leia / Han Solo dynamic as they duet on the catchiest of the film's new songs, Princess Problems. What this means is that Disney's Snow White now has not one but two merry bands of forest-dwellers. You can only assume that one draft of the screenplay had the human outlaws, and another draft had the time-honoured, cottage-sharing dwarfs, and the producers just shrugged and decided to keep both of them. This was a bizarre mistake. Why introduce seven dwarfs if they then have nothing significant to do? Why introduce a magical mine of precious stones if it's not used in the story? Webb would have been better off keeping Jonathan's gang, and cutting the dwarfs – and not just because they look so grotesque.

The film's split personality problems don't go away. Half of it is set in a grimy, gloomy land where Snow White wants to foment a peasants' revolt and restore a socialist utopia, but half of it is set in a chirpy, brightly-coloured fantasy realm of benign and beautiful aristocrats. Half the time, the characters are belting out overwrought, self-empowerment anthems by Benj Pasek and Justin Paul, the songsmiths behind The Greatest Showman. But half the time they're trilling the jaunty 1937 ditties by Frank Churchill and Larry Morey.

Perhaps we should appreciate the value for money: the studio is in effect giving us two films for the price of one. But the producers should have picked a lane and stayed in it. As it is, Disney's Snow White keeps veering between two aesthetics and two eras, so it never picks up momentum. The story is cluttered, the tone is muddled, and the pacing is off. Again, that doesn't make the film a disaster. In some ways, the identity crisis is what makes it worth seeing. But this muddled production will be enjoyed more by politics and cinema students than by children who are hoping to be enchanted by Disney magic.

★★★☆☆

--  

If you liked this story, sign up for The Essential List newsletter – a handpicked selection of features, videos and can't-miss news, delivered to your inbox twice a week.

For more Culture stories from the BBC, follow us on Facebook, X and Instagram. 

Film ReviewsDisneyComment & AnalysisWatchHow fears of inflation could impact interest rates

Consumer inflation expectations could creep into the Federal Reserve's calculations on interest rates.

4 hrs agoWorld of BusinessThis machine turns carbon dioxide into fuel

Researchers have found a way to take carbon dioxide and turn it into syngas, creating carbon-neutral energy.

21 hrs agoGreen livingGold hits fresh highs amid rising geopolitical uncertainty

Jeffrey Sherman, Deputy CIO at DoubleLine, says geopolitical shocks and US policy uncertainty feeds into markets.

1 day agoOpening BellHow sex with Neanderthals changed us forever

We find out what we gained when Homo sapiens mated with Homo neanderthalensis many thousands of years ago.

1 day agoScienceWhy does Japan have a reserve of rice?

What is a "strategic reserve" and why does Japan have one for rice?

2 days agoWorld of BusinessCould markets make Trump reconsider tariffs? - 17 Mar 2025

Expert says that US President Trump might have no option but to U-turn if markets continue to fall.

2 days agoOpening BellWhy Elton John burst into tears after recording a song

The musician explains a heavy moment thinking about the lyrics of a song from his forthcoming album.

2 days agoMusicBosnia's daredevil divers jump off Mostar's UNESCO bridge

The Travel Show goes to Bosnia to meet divers jumping from a 24-metre-high UNESCO listed bridge.

2 days agoThe Travel ShowTeatro alla Scala: See the magic and mystery of opera

From Verdi to Bellini, this legendary stage has been the heart of music and performance for centuries.

2 days agoArts in MotionWeek in Markets - 14 March 2025

A weekly summary of the big stories from financial markets around the world.

5 days agoWorld of BusinessHow the first 'sensational' picture of Lady Diana came about

It starts nearly 40 years ago, when a teenage girl is pulled out of obscurity and thrust into the spotlight.

5 days agoPhotographyMarket turmoil is normal, expert says - 14 Mar 2025

Market turmoil is quite normal and nothing to worry about, Chuck Lieberman of Advisors Capital Management says.

5 days agoOpening BellJapan's solution to the solar panel waste problem

As billions of solar panels near the end of their lifespan, Japan looks at innovative solutions to recycle them.

5 days agoTechXploreMany products hit by more than one tariff - 13 Mar 2025

Expert says that tariffs could make up as much as 70% of the final price.

6 days agoOpening BellInside one of the world's most water-efficient cities

Fukuoka, a city on Japan's Kyushu island, uses cutting-edge technology such as satellites and AI to save water.

6 days agoTechXploreWhat snow can teach us about street design

Snowfall is helping urban planners design safer and more pleasant streets in the US.

7 days agoClimate solutionsInvestors nervous about Trump tariff outcome - 12 Mar 2025

Expert says other factors may balance out some of the inflationary impact of tariffs.

7 days agoOpening BellThe Japanese farm turning cow manure into hydrogen fuel

Some dairy cattle in Hokkaido are not only producing milk but also fuelling a more sustainable future.

7 days agoTechXploreChris Pratt on having Schwarzenegger as his father-in-law

The actor reveals his rituals with his famous father-in-law, including 'letting him win' at chess.

11 Mar 2025Film & TVHow AI is booming in China

China is embracing AI in its bid to become a tech superpower by 2030.

11 Mar 2025World of BusinessMore4 days agoHow Snow White became 2025's most divisive film

The live-action version of the classic fairy-tale animation sounded like a surefire hit. But even before it's reached cinemas, the response to it has been loud and often hostile.

4 days agoCulture6 days agoDisney holds small-scale Snow White premiere amid controversy

The film is being released as debate continues about the way dwarfs re represented

6 days agoCulture3 Mar 2025Why the Oscars require 'a major shake-up'

This year's ceremony featured a bizarre James Bond tribute – while failing to duly honour visionary director David Lynch. That choice spoke to the awards' profound identity crisis.

3 Mar 2025Culture2 Mar 2025The unstoppable rise of the 'domestic goddess'

From Martha Stewart to Meghan: Why there's no stopping the TV celebrity homemaker – and why "we're in a retro domestic goddess moment".

2 Mar 2025Culture23 Feb 2025Disney series offers 'different narrative' of Jamaican Londoners

Actors Malachi Kirby and Francis Lovehall say the Disney+ series offers a unique view of Jamaicans in Victorian London.

23 Feb 2025London