'It's exactly what the country needs': How Brazil propelled drama I'm Still Here to be this year's Oscars dark horse8 hours agoCaryn JamesCourtesy of Sony Pictures Classics

Starring Fernanda Torres and centring on a family torn apart by Brazil's military dictatorship, I'm Still Here is up for three major awards – and could pull off an upset on the night.

When the Oscar nominations were announced, the surprising strength of Walter Salles's I'm Still Here – with nods for Fernanda Torres as best actress, best international film and most unexpected of all best picture – caused celebrations in Brazil. "I'm so proud! Kisses to Fernanda Torres and Walter Salles," the country's president, Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva, posted on X. Emotionally powerful and eloquent, the film tells the real-life story of a family living under Brazil's two-decade military dictatorship, which ended in 1985. In 1971, Rubens Paiva (Selton Mello), a former congressman, was taken by military police and never seen again, leaving his wife, Eunice (Torres), to create a future for herself and her five children. In the following years, as Eunice returns to school and becomes a prominent human rights lawyer, she never stops trying to find the truth about her husband's fate and to hold the state accountable. And on the day the nominations were announced, 23 January, the film and reality intersected again. Paiva's death certificate, which had declared him missing, was amended to reflect the reality that his death was "violent, caused by the Brazilian state".

Sony Pictures ClassicsFernanda Torres plays Eunice Paiva, the wife of congressman Rubens, who was taken by Brazilian military police in 1971 and never seen again (Credit: Sony Pictures Classics)

I'm Still Here is an Oscar dark horse and much more. It now looks like the frontrunner in the international category, and Torres has at least a realistic chance of upsetting the best actress frontrunner, Demi Moore. Behind those nominations is an alchemical mix of the personal, the political and the artistic. Few films have depicted the devastating effects of politics on individuals in such an intimate, visceral or timely way, arriving at a moment when the rise of authoritarianism has become a global concern.

"I was always tempted by filmic narratives in which the journey of the characters somehow blends with the journey of a country," Salles tells the BBC. And while the film is explicitly about the Brazilian dictatorship, and has been a big commercial hit in that country – becoming the highest-grossing homegrown film there since the pandemic – it has also touched audiences around the world. Its global box-office numbers are remarkable for a low-budget film: more than $25m, including more than $3m in just a month in the US, where it is still playing strongly in cinemas.

Why Brazil has got behind it

The film's awards journey has been propelled by its impact in Brazil, where Torres is a major star with an enormous social media following. Isabela Boscov, a Brazilian journalist and film critic, tells the BBC: "What is really unusual in Brazil is a film that is not a comedy having that sort of box office. That hasn't happened in years and years." She attributes the success to a combination of factors, including Torres's popularity, how realistically the film captures 1970s Brazil, and the national mood. The country's recent history has been tumultuous. Jair Bolsonaro's far-right government was in power from 2019 to 2023. When he lost the 2022 election, his supporters stormed the Congress, presidential palace and Supreme Court, and last year Bolsonaro was formally accused of allegedly plotting a coup. "Walter Salles has this gift for encapsulating exactly what the country needs, for really touching the zeitgeist," Boscov says. "At the moment Brazil is a very divided country in terms of thought and ideology. And I think half of the country would like to face whatever happened in the past [during the dictatorship], so as to prevent it from happening again.

Lais Morais/ ReutersA photograph of the real Paiva family, including Eunice and Rubens – director Walter Salles knew them personally as a teenager (Credit: Lais Morais/ Reuters)

All the attention and manoeuvring wouldn't have mattered, of course, if voters and audiences weren't responding so strongly to the film itself. Although it deals with tragedy, it is also full of warmth, and begins with scenes of the Paiva family and their friends, laughing and dancing at dinners and at the beach, living a full life.  Salles knew the family personally as a young teenager in Rio de Janeiro. "I was invited into that house, into the intimacy of that family. I was enamoured of it," he says. Recreating its atmosphere is a way of welcoming viewers into the film. The family is always aware of the dangers around them, though. Driving home from a film, one of the teenage daughters and her friends is pulled over and questioned by police.

The long road to production

Salles's films include Central Station (1998), which was also nominated for the international film Oscar and, with what turns out to be poignant symmetry, in the best actress category for Torres's mother, Fernanda Montenegro, who plays the older Eunice in I'm Still Here. Creating I'm Still Here took seven years, he says, partly because "there were so many layers of memory involved that I wanted to be faithful to". He was inspired to make the film after reading the 2015 memoir by Rubens and Eunice's son, Marcelo Paiva, who began writing it when "his mother, who had fought to preserve the family's memory for decades, was falling into the abyss of Alzheimer's, and therefore losing her memory at a time where the country was starting to lose its collective memory," Salles says. That story offered what he calls "a double reflection" on the past.

Reminding viewers of his country's past was crucial to Salles, and was another reason getting the film made took so long. "It would have been unthinkable to shoot this film during the Bolsonaro years," he says. "We would not have had permission to shoot in public spaces. Basically, we would have been able to shoot the interiors, but not the exteriors of the film. This certainly added three or four years to the development."

More like this:

• Why it's one of the closest Oscar races ever

• Category fraud is the latest Oscars scandal

• The real-life history behind The Brutalist  

Salles says of the real-life woman, "Eunice is a character who refused melodrama," a quality that infuses the film and Torres's sophisticated, powerfully restrained performance. As she watches her husband taken away from their front door, calmly driving his own car as if to a friendly meeting, Eunice gives a slight, reassuring smile, but her face is a wrenching image of sorrow beneath the calm facade. Torres always allows us to see the grief and pain beneath the restraint. After Rubens' disappearance, Salles says, she was determined "not to bend to an authoritarian regime, never to allow herself to be portrayed as a victim". He points to "this extraordinary idea of whenever they wanted her to cry on camera, she would do the exact opposite, which is to smile". A scene in the film recreates just that, when a journalist asks the family not to smile for a photograph, and Eunice insists that they do.

Getty ImagesTorres' win for best actress in a drama at the Golden Globes followed her mother Fernanda Montenegro's nomination for another Salles film, Central Station (Credit: Getty Images)

It took until 1996 for her to get a death certificate at all, the first one that erroneously listed the cause of death as "missing". In the film she proudly shows reporters the certificate and says, "Forced disappearances were one of the cruellest acts of the regime because you kill one person but condemn all the others to eternal psychological torture." Capturing that enduring grief and uncertainty is one of the film's most original, affecting accomplishments.

Even Salles couldn't have foreseen exactly how timely the film might become, although he says, "When we shot the film, we were already aware that the fragility of democracy was something that wasn't only pertinent to Brazil anymore. It was pertinent to too many countries in the world." One of the first things authoritarians routinely do, he says, is "to try to erase memory and somewhat rewrite history". Preserving that memory and history, personal and political, goes to the heart of I'm Still Here. Salles says: "I think one of the reasons the film echoed so strongly in Brazil with audiences is because they were embracing the humanity of that family, but they were also seeing a reflection of themselves on the screen, and they were accessing a part of Brazilian history that had been forgotten for too long."

I'm Still Here is out in US cinemas now and released in the UK on 21 February.

-- 

If you liked this story, sign up for The Essential List newsletter – a handpicked selection of features, videos and can't-miss news, delivered to your inbox twice a week.  

For more Culture stories from the BBC, follow us on Facebook, X and Instagram. 

Oscars 2025Awards WatchFeaturesWatchA 'clinic in a box' that can check whether you're healthy

The 'clinic' in a box' is a remote doctor's appointment that can take place anywhere.

9 hrs agoInnovationBovine language: Studying how cows talk to each other

Leonie Cornips, a sociolinguist at the Meertens Institute in Amsterdam, turns her attention from humans to cows.

9 hrs agoFuture Planet'If you're nominated, you've already won'

Nine-time Oscar nominee Robert De Niro offers his words of wisdom to first-time nominee Mikey Madison.

1 day agoFilm & TVThe 2,000-year-old history of animal gift giving

Before panda diplomacy, there was elephant diplomacy. We spoke to a foreign affairs expert to find out more.

1 day agoWorld of wonderHew Locke on why art is important in a fractious world

The renowned British sculptor challenges viewers to pause, reflect, and question his art.

2 days agoArts in MotionBosnia's 'war secret' that stopped Sarajevo from falling

BBC Travel presenter Rajan Datar explores a secret tunnel that protected citizens during the siege of Sarajevo.

2 days agoThe Travel ShowNothing brings more freedom than filmmaking, Jia Zhang-Ke

Renowned Chinese filmmaker Jia Zhang-Ke reflects on how he sees cinema as a space for freedom and rebellion.

2 days agoArts in MotionHow Anthony Mackie found out he was Captain America

The actor describes the moment Chris Evans revealed to him that he would be the next super hero.

3 days agoFilm & TVMarkets digest week of mounting tariffs - 14 Feb 2025

Expert says it's difficult for investors to discern what the best course of action is.

5 days agoOpening BellThe insulting 'Vinegar Valentine' of Victorian England

Valentine’s Day is thought to celebrate romance but rude cards soured the holiday for its recipients.

6 days agoHistoryJanuary inflation results higher than expected - 13 Feb 2025

US wholesale inflation rose more than expected in January, adding to inflation concerns.

6 days agoOpening BellInside Usonia: A 1940s utopian town in the United States

100-year-old Roland Reisley is the last original member of Usonia, a small visionary community in the woods.

6 days agoThe SpeciaListTracey Emin: 'Making art about rape and sex is important'

Tracey Emin, once the British art world's 'enfant terrible', talks art and life with the BBC.

6 days ago100 Women ExtraUS Fed 'unlikely to cut rates in short term' - 12 Feb 2025

Carol Schleif, Chief Strategist at BMO Private Wealth, says it's unlikely the Fed will cut interest rates soon.

7 days agoOpening BellTheory of Evolution: How did Charles Darwin come up with it?

The British naturalist embarked on an extraordinary journey, did hundreds of experiments, and wrote for 20 years.

7 days agoScienceTariffs 'unlikely to boost US metal industry' - 11 Feb 2025

Scott Lincicome at the US think tank Cato Institute says Trump's steel tariffs could hurt manufacturing.

11 Feb 2025Opening BellWhy 'snowy' New York winters are a bit of a myth

While New York winters are often depicted as snowy wonderlands, the city's never been as snowy as you think.

11 Feb 2025Weather & scienceMikey Madison on learning to pole dance for Anora

Mikey Madison tells Graham Norton that she spent five months pole dance training for her role in Anora.

11 Feb 2025Film & TVRichard III: The 'accidental' photo of a long-lost king

Why a famous photograph of King Richard III's skeleton was a happy 'accident'.

11 Feb 2025HistoryMarket impact from steel tariffs 'muted' - 10 Feb 2025

Strategist says market impact is muted after steel tariffs, but investors are concerned about long-term effects.

10 Feb 2025Opening BellMore6 hrs agoCanada's accessible dark-sky sanctuary

Spanning 11,000 sq km of protected, pristine wilderness, Jasper National Park offers a one-of-a-kind destination for stargazers.

6 hrs agoTravel9 hrs agoWhen should you throw away your kitchen sponge?

We use them to clean the dishes we eat off, but your kitchen sponge is a damp, crumb-filled environment that is perfect for bacteria to thrive in. Is a washing up brush better?

9 hrs agoFuture1 day agoIs it time to change how we buy travel souvenirs?

The BBC looks into the psychology behind travel souvenirs: why we buy them, their impact on local communities and the planet, and how we can shop more thoughtfully.

1 day agoTravel1 day agoHow one surprising image kick-started the 1990s

An iconic image of Kate Moss marked an explosive moment of change in Britain – and helped to create the culture we now live in. It's among the photos displayed in a new exhibition.

1 day agoCulture1 day agoHow a tiny village became India's YouTube capital

In Tulsi, a village in central India, social media has sparked an economic and social revolution. It's a microcosm of YouTube's effect on the world.

1 day agoFuture